Cav & Pag Reviews
Last week the Guildford Opera Company presented a double bill, ‘Cav and Pag’, with their production of two one act operas: Cavalleria Rusticana and Pagliacci.
Both are tales of Italian passion, jealousy and betrayal. Sung in English and accompanied by a chamber orchestra, the Electric Theatre audience was in receptive mood. Both operas offer familiar and much loved themes, which I tend to associate with Desert Island Discs. It was therefore, rousing to hear them performed live and experience an operatic delivery powering it to the auditorium.
It’s an excitement a CD cannot replicate.
Guildford opera blends together professional soloists, an astonishing orchestra and a talented amateur chorus but inevitably it operates within a budget.
On this occasion the staging and costuming seemed to emphasise that fact.
The set design, although offering different levels, was minimal with the costuming given a modern twist. When additionally viewed against the basic movement and lighting plots I had to reluctantly accept the company was prudently cutting its cloth.
On the plus side the stage simplicity allowed the story lines and music to stand hauntingly alone but I was left wondering what if the stage setting was enhanced, what if there was period costuming, and what could splashes of colour add to the Italian passion and despair we were watching?
The Guildford Chorus was on excellent form with sterling work by the sopranos and tenors but by the interval I was convinced this challenging double bill could have been the occasion to go all out for a strong concert version, conjuring the evening dress sophistication the GOC chorus has, in the past, so easily achieved.
By playing to strengths, I suspect this would have captured a stronger professional feel.
I should report the evening ended with repeated curtain calls, shouts of Bravo, some enthusiastic stomping and sustained applause.
One member of the audience made a point of telling me he had enjoyed “ a brilliant evening”. I agree – musically!
Published 29th November 2024
Noda South East Review
The performance of Cavalleria Rusticana and Pagliacci was a stunning example of verismo opera, capturing the raw emotion and dramatic tension of late 19th-century Italian life. Set in impoverished rural communities—Sicily and Calabria, respectively—both operas were linked by their portrayal of simple, working-class people dealing with love, betrayal, and social conflict, all set against the backdrop of a feast day celebration. The productions were further unified by their intermezzos, adding to the rich, immersive experience.
The atmosphere in the theatre was electric, with eager anticipation evident both in the foyer and the auditorium. The programme provided a wealth of background material, including insightful photographs and pen pictures that enriched the audience’s understanding of the works. The set design, minimalist yet effective, used rostra strategically placed on stage to create focal points, allowing the action to unfold within a simple yet evocative framework. Lighting played a key role, highlighting the drama of each scene.
The costuming was thoughtfully executed, with Cavalleria Rusticana focusing on the stark contrasts of black and white, in keeping with the sombre, impoverished setting. The addition of a mantilla for the church scene added authenticity. In Pagliacci, blue served as the dominant colour, creating a brighter, more vibrant atmosphere. The costumes were simple but effective, reinforcing the emotional tone of the operas.
The orchestra, reduced in size to evoke the intimacy of chamber music, was a highlight. The combination of four woodwind instruments, a single horn, double bass, piano, and percussion provided both subtlety and power. The smaller ensemble allowed the vocal performances to shine while still providing the necessary drama when called for.
In Cavalleria Rusticana, the cast gave powerful performances. Anna Goodhew portrayed Santuzza with emotional depth, capturing both her isolation and inner strength. Gisela Hendricks’ Mama Lucia was endearing, balancing maternal warmth with a sharp sense of duty. Oswaldo Iraheta as Turiddu convincingly embodied the flawed womanizer, with his tenor voice adding emotional weight to his tragic fate. George Contes’ Alfio was a menacing force, and Rachel Garland’s Lola brought a touch of charm and complexity to her role.
Pagliacci began with a poignant prologue by Simon Wilson as Tonio, setting the tone for the tragic drama to follow. The cast of strolling players, led by Matt Connelly’s Canio, was dynamic and well-executed. Connelly’s portrayal of Canio was understated yet deeply moving, while Callie Gaston’s Nedda brought energy and passion to her role as wife and lover. Ben Watkins as Silvio delivered his lines with clarity and emotion, though a more commanding posture would have enhanced his character’s authority. Richard Milne’s Beppe provided a refreshing vocal contribution.
The chorus, ever more engaged in the unfolding drama, helped bring the village setting to life, contributing to the immersive atmosphere. Overall, the evening was a high-quality operatic experience, and the audience was fortunate to witness such a remarkable production by Guildford Opera.
Author: Kay Rowan, 23rd November 2024